WITH a British teenager having suffered a severe allergic reaction to vaping, users fear the alternative to cigarettes could carry hidden dangers.
But while a German professor warned that e-cigs might harm the brain, lungs, heart and blood vessels, the extent of the risk remains unclear. Here, British expert Professor PETER HAJEK answers the big questions.
The risks of e-cigarettes remain unclear after a teenager suffered a severe allergic reaction to vaping
The risks of e-cigarettes remain unclear after a teenager suffered a severe allergic reaction to vapingCredit: iStock - Getty
ISN’T vaping supposed to be safer than smoking?
Yes, vaping is much less dangerous than smoking tobacco. For smokers who switch to vaping, they will remove the risks to their health by a factor of 95 per cent. The risk of cancer, heart disease and lung disease can be expected to be substantially reduced, too. The current estimate is that vaping poses less than five per cent of the risks of smoking cigarettes.
CAN vaping kill you?
There have been no deaths from vaping nicotine e-cigarettes of the type used in the UK.
WHAT about the case of teen Ewan Fisher, from Nottingham, whose lungs were affected by vaping?
It looks like this case might have been the result of a rare allergic reaction to one of the ingredients in an e-cigarette. There are 3.6million vapers in the UK and this is the first such case.
WHAT about reports of deaths in the United States?
The outbreak of lung injury in America is due to contaminants in illegally-produced marijuana/THC cartridges.
This has nothing to do with the type of e-cigarettes that are used by smokers in the UK.
SHOULD vapers be worried about the report by Prof Thomas Munzel in Mainz, Germany, which claims that vaping can harm the brain, heart, lungs and blood vessels?
This report found two things. In humans, nicotine from e-cigarettes produced a typical short-term stimulant effect, also seen after drinking coffee, that on its own signals no danger. In mice and in tissue samples, acrolein – a chemical that can be generated when e-liquid is fried – had more damaging effects. This, however, is not relevant for human vapers.
DOES vaping pose no risk?
There is likely to be some risk from vaping. But the data we have so far is only from people who have vaped for two or three years and this raised no serious health concerns.
IS vaping addictive?
Vaping seems to satisfy smokers who are already used to nicotine, but it does not appear to be very appealing or addictive for non-smokers. It is rare for non- smokers to go on to become daily vapers.
The Sun says
THE hysteria over vaping’s perils is absurd. In an ideal world no one would vape or smoke. But the world isn’t ideal and cigarettes are vastly more dangerous.It would be mad to follow other countries and ban vaping, given its huge *success in getting smokers to quit.Yes, there are isolated scares and even deaths in the US where the market — unlike ours — is almost unregulated. But smoking kills 20 A DAY in the UK.Vaping saves lives. End the backlash.
MOST READ IN NEWS
BUG OUTBREAK Norovirus alert as vomiting bug hits hospital and NHS says stay at home
HEARTLESS Staff at scandal-hit hospital told mum to ‘keep the noise down’ as newborn died
WETHERS-POO-N Wetherspoon norovirus outbreak leaves customers 'shooting from both ends'
AS BAD AS CIGGIES Living in a polluted city is 'equal to smoking 150 cigarettes a year'
QUARANTINED Patient diagnosed with monkeypox on return to UK from Nigeria, officials say
FREAK TRAGEDY Fit & healthy teen died after 'turning head too quickly triggered stroke'
WHY isn’t vaping as addictive as smoking?
Nicotine is highly addictive when it is combined with other chemicals in tobacco. It is not very addictive in the form of nicotine replacement treatments, such as nicotine chewing gum or nicotine inhalator, or in e-cigarettes in their current form.
But while a German professor warned that e-cigs might harm the brain, lungs, heart and blood vessels, the extent of the risk remains unclear. Here, British expert Professor PETER HAJEK answers the big questions.
The risks of e-cigarettes remain unclear after a teenager suffered a severe allergic reaction to vaping
The risks of e-cigarettes remain unclear after a teenager suffered a severe allergic reaction to vapingCredit: iStock - Getty
ISN’T vaping supposed to be safer than smoking?
Yes, vaping is much less dangerous than smoking tobacco. For smokers who switch to vaping, they will remove the risks to their health by a factor of 95 per cent. The risk of cancer, heart disease and lung disease can be expected to be substantially reduced, too. The current estimate is that vaping poses less than five per cent of the risks of smoking cigarettes.
CAN vaping kill you?
There have been no deaths from vaping nicotine e-cigarettes of the type used in the UK.
WHAT about the case of teen Ewan Fisher, from Nottingham, whose lungs were affected by vaping?
It looks like this case might have been the result of a rare allergic reaction to one of the ingredients in an e-cigarette. There are 3.6million vapers in the UK and this is the first such case.
WHAT about reports of deaths in the United States?
The outbreak of lung injury in America is due to contaminants in illegally-produced marijuana/THC cartridges.
This has nothing to do with the type of e-cigarettes that are used by smokers in the UK.
SHOULD vapers be worried about the report by Prof Thomas Munzel in Mainz, Germany, which claims that vaping can harm the brain, heart, lungs and blood vessels?
This report found two things. In humans, nicotine from e-cigarettes produced a typical short-term stimulant effect, also seen after drinking coffee, that on its own signals no danger. In mice and in tissue samples, acrolein – a chemical that can be generated when e-liquid is fried – had more damaging effects. This, however, is not relevant for human vapers.
DOES vaping pose no risk?
There is likely to be some risk from vaping. But the data we have so far is only from people who have vaped for two or three years and this raised no serious health concerns.
IS vaping addictive?
Vaping seems to satisfy smokers who are already used to nicotine, but it does not appear to be very appealing or addictive for non-smokers. It is rare for non- smokers to go on to become daily vapers.
The Sun says
THE hysteria over vaping’s perils is absurd. In an ideal world no one would vape or smoke. But the world isn’t ideal and cigarettes are vastly more dangerous.It would be mad to follow other countries and ban vaping, given its huge *success in getting smokers to quit.Yes, there are isolated scares and even deaths in the US where the market — unlike ours — is almost unregulated. But smoking kills 20 A DAY in the UK.Vaping saves lives. End the backlash.
MOST READ IN NEWS
BUG OUTBREAK Norovirus alert as vomiting bug hits hospital and NHS says stay at home
HEARTLESS Staff at scandal-hit hospital told mum to ‘keep the noise down’ as newborn died
WETHERS-POO-N Wetherspoon norovirus outbreak leaves customers 'shooting from both ends'
AS BAD AS CIGGIES Living in a polluted city is 'equal to smoking 150 cigarettes a year'
QUARANTINED Patient diagnosed with monkeypox on return to UK from Nigeria, officials say
FREAK TRAGEDY Fit & healthy teen died after 'turning head too quickly triggered stroke'
WHY isn’t vaping as addictive as smoking?
Nicotine is highly addictive when it is combined with other chemicals in tobacco. It is not very addictive in the form of nicotine replacement treatments, such as nicotine chewing gum or nicotine inhalator, or in e-cigarettes in their current form.